More in Common
·
2023

Searching for a New Paradigm: Collective Settings

Key Finding

Community “collective settings” built on participatory governance, accountability, and openness to difference and experimentation build democratic capacity more effectively than top-down reform alone, three in-depth case studies find.

About this research

This November 2023 white paper from More in Common and the SNF Agora Institute at Johns Hopkins University examines “collective settings” — community spaces where people work together on shared problems — as an underused lever for democratic renewal. Drawing on 47 interviews and field observation across three in-depth case studies (the depolarization organization Braver Angels, Alaska’s ranked-choice voting reform process, and a forest-management partnership called Blue Mountain Forest Partners), it identifies four design features shared by settings that build trust and civic capacity: participatory governance, accountability, an embrace of difference, and room to experiment.
Format

White Paper

Year

2023

Published by

More in Common, with the SNF Agora Institute at Johns Hopkins University

Category

Effectiveness Evidence

Keep Reading

More research in this category

Study

Reducing Islamophobia: An Assessment of Psychological Mechanisms That Underlie Anti-Islamophobia Media Interventions

Beyond Conflict
·
2023
Key Finding
An intervention tournament testing 11 practitioner-developed videos found that interventions prompting recognition of media bias against Muslims reduced anti-Muslim hostility, both immediately and one month later.
Effectiveness Evidence

Evaluation Report

The Dignity Index Pilot Project Technical Summary

UNITE / Dignity.Us
·
2023
Key Finding
Documents a controlled pilot (Sept 2022) testing whether the 8-point Dignity Index scale can be reliably taught and applied by university students across the political spectrum.
Effectiveness Evidence

Study

Action Over Dialogue: The Case for Prioritizing Local Civic Engagement

Trust for Civic Life
·
2025
Key Finding
A 500+-respondent survey across eight rural communities found that joint local action, not dialogue alone, is what actually builds social trust and belonging — a useful evidence check for dialogue-centered practitioners.
Effectiveness Evidence

Join Our Community

Stay current with the field — funding, jobs, news, and events delivered to practitioners.